Blog post

Rethinking retirement: how lack of government outreach on the pension plan led to audience backlash

Indonesia’s newly proposed Mandatory Additional Pension Plan aims to ensure long-term financial security for workers while addressing the challenges of an aging population and growing public welfare demands. However, the initiative has sparked mixed reactions, with debates on fairness, implementation, and its potential impact on the economy. In our report we explore the policy’s implications, public sentiment, and the steps needed to foster trust and acceptance.

The vision behind the plan: securing financial stability

The pension program aims to increase the retirement replacement ratio in line with International Labour Organization (ILO) standards. It targets private-sector employees earning above a certain threshold, requiring payroll deductions to fund future pensions. This initiative could reduce long-term reliance on public welfare systems while encouraging savings culture among workers. However, the program’s perceived complexity and lack of clarity have created a communication gap​.

Is it an immediate burden or long-term gain?

Many workers and stakeholders worry about reduced take-home pay and short-term financial strain. The “mandatory but voluntary” nature of the program has added confusion, with scepticism about its fairness and trust in government fund management.

Administrative and wage pressures on employers

For employers, the program introduces new administrative complexities and potential wage pressures, particularly for small and medium enterprises (SMEs). Providing support, such as phased implementation and incentives, could ease the transition and encourage wider adoption​.

In the short term, the pension plan may reduce consumer spending due to lower disposable incomes. However, it promises long-term economic benefits by fostering savings growth and reducing dependency on public welfare systems. In such instances, clear policies will be crucial in mitigating the initial economic challenges​.

Building Trust

The success of the program depends heavily on transparent communication, robust safeguards, and phased implementation to address concerns. Providing incentives for additional contributions and collaborating with employers and workers to refine the plan could enhance its acceptance and sustainability​.

Indonesia’s Mandatory Additional Pension Plan highlights the region’s growing focus on securing financial stability in an aging society. While the policy holds promise for long-term benefits, careful planning and adaptive strategies will be vital to its success. This initiative could set a benchmark for sustainable pension reform across Southeast Asia.

Want to catch up to our latest insights and reports? Contact nikita.gundala@isentia.com to learn more.